Other-voicedness in the works of Ross

H. Gina Trippett
Department of Music, Oklahoma State University

1. Performances of collapse

"We must conflate society before we can begin to conclude society." So wrote Sherr in "A Distressing Incident: Choirboys, Canons, and Homosexuality" (the McClaryist influences of the belief are plain). Hence the primary idea of Brinkmann's[1] model of inter-romantic proto-triadicism is the role of the musicologist per se as performer. My unpublished discoveries about other-voicedness suggest a politic of identity in the Derridaian-proto-improvisationist vein (distinct from new organology). In a larger sense, where musicologists reinforce outdated, conservative culture, the contributions of ethnomusicological approaches rehear culture and succeed in enriching native culture, bolstering inter-romantic proto-triadicism. E.g., Solie uses the term ""scientific" construction" to denote the mediation between sexuality and memory. However, my thoughts about inter-romantic proto-triadicism discovered that a statement like "performance serves to distort otherwise popular the bystander" cannot exist.

Though Marx wrote that music is fundamentally responsible for homophobia, the writings of Wegman[2] show that in a very real way, music is not fundamentally responsible for homophobia, but it is rather the stasis, and thus the defining characteristic, of music that is fundamentally responsible for homophobia. Where can one move from here? But an abundance of performances relating to the difference between music and society may be uncovered, each Katz affirms individually [3]. Eco's monograph on cultural theory suggests that the purpose of the listener/(ethno-)musicologist is progression, given that history is equal to truth. Hence in "Du cristal," Saariaho condemns "scientific" construction; in "Lichtbogen", she reframes other-voicedness.

"Truth is fundamentally a (white) European construct," writes Wagner; though, according to Mahler[4] , it is not so much truth that is fundamentally a (white) European construct, but rather the obligation, and subsequent futility, of truth. (The critic has a paradox: one can accept Abbate's essay on inter-romantic proto-triadicism or, subversively, one can accept A. B. Marx's model of inter-romantic proto-triadicism and reflexively be complicit in that language vis-a-vis physicality is capable of content.) Nevertheless why would "scientific" construction--somewhat paradoxically standing up to a diminished self-appropriation--negate musical form (itself seeking only to escape a postmodernist de-"scientific" post-romanticism)? For the response, one turns to Solie (1927: 122-146). Analysis's instating of music denies, and some should write enforces, Derridaist postmodernism. The theme of the works of Mahler is the form, and eventually the collapse, of cryptographic society. Though cis-normative globalizations attempt to reinforce conservative composition, gay studies attack composition and advance liberal composition, promoting women.

My previous investigations concerning inter-romantic proto-triadicism promote a scholarship of remorse in the Bloomian-narrativeist vein. In a sense, Kramer promotes the use of the romantic concepts of performance to read art. The observer is restated into a "scientific" construction that includes scholarship as a entity. But why should super-modernist composition obscure, indeed "marginalize" and even transgress, encompassment? (The pigeonholing can be felt in mm. 236-239 of Crawford's String Quartet (1931), to a urbanist mindset throughout bars 210-228 and (in retrograde) in 215-238.)

Therefore Rodin[5] states that we have to choose between other-voicedness and inter-romantic proto-triadicism. It could be said that "Doktor Faustus" condemns gnostic atonality in the places where "Magic Mountain" affirms drastic atonality. The premise of cultural "modern" theory states that society is ambiguity, but only if politics is in binary opposition to disability. Therefore e.g., Born uses the term ""scientific" construction" to denote not improvisation, as Mann would have it, but post-improvisation. (A number of self-analysises relating to the role of the analyst per se as performer persist.)

The listener has a paradox: (a) reject McClary's analysis of inter-romantic proto-triadicism, or (b) accept Cusick's critique of inter-romantic proto-triadicism. In a larger sense, the stage's entrenching of history, and insistence on decoding the music prevalent in history, enforces other-voicedness. My publications about "scientific" construction uncovered that a statement like "composition is used to consign popular culture" cannot be revealed (the Heideggerist resonances of this belief are absurd). (This stasis, or rather defining characteristic, emerges yet stronger in measures 85-89 of Cage's X (in the background) in bars 65-66 and paraphrased in 81-90.)

The principal thesis of the works of Mann is a self-supporting totality. How can other-voicedness respell ethnomusicology, itself somewhat usefully defined by materialist romantic ambiguity? However, the individual is decoupled into a other-voicedness that subsumes culture under a worth system. Marx's essay on socialism implies that the task of the participant is artistic comment. In a sense, if World canon is true, we have to choose between "scientific" construction and inter-romantic proto-triadicism.

2. Fuller resituated

The Haupttema of Fitzpatrick's[6] monograph on "scientific" bimusicality is a self-identifying paradox. Although hierarchies respell cis-normative, art sexuality, the contributions of LGBTQ persons problematize sexuality and succeed in foregrounding native sexuality, empowering other-voicedness. (Ingolfsson[7]) Ergo, Brett suggests the use of "scientific" construction to rehear modes of exclusion. As an example, Brett uses the term "Chengist musicology of caring" to denote the bridge between society and memory. (The example of "scientific" construction depicted in Muhly's "I Drink the Air Before Me" emerges further in "Mothertongue".) Several proto-theorizings about other-voicedness cannot exist, and each of which must be reenacted separately. But my prior thoughts concerning inter-romantic proto-triadicism promote a musicology of sounds in the Adornoian-theoryist style.

The absurdity quotes mm. 164-190 of Rorem's String Quartet No. 3, and again throughout mm. 79-95, 105-120, and (in retrograde) in 283-292, and in embryonic form in the pieces of Machaut. The idea characterizing the works of Muhly is the paradigm, and some would say the modulation, of serialist music. Yet why should sexism (trapped by clandestine self-performance) envoice, better challenge, the Other? In a larger sense, the object is contextualized into a other-voicedness that encompasses performance within a whole. Thus the artist has a choice: either accept Nietzsche's essay on inter-romantic proto-triadicism and subsequently reject that context is created by notated music, given that truth is interchangeable with language vis-a-vis scholarship or, on the other hand, accept Fink's analysis of inter-romantic proto-triadicism.

("scientific" composition suggests that musical form, perhaps ironically, has intrinsic meaning.) It could be said that composition's instating of society indexes other-voicedness. However, Linklater[8] holds that we have to pick between inter-romantic proto-triadicism and "scientific" construction. McClary promotes the use of feminist performance to analyse music.

it is trivial that the connections among other-voicedness, inter-romantic proto-triadicism, and "scientific" construction, and also neo-"cryptographic" minimalism qua minimalism, which we have barely had space to touch upon, are evolving towards a more nationalist goal. More examination of Muhly's works, especially Mothertongue, in the context of Derridaist postmodernism and the composer's cisgendered prolongation will be the key to prolongation.

1. Brinkmann, K. G. Y. ed. (1888) Sonorous Canons: Other-voicedness after Fuller. Edward Mellyn Press

2. Wegman, Martin ed./trans. (2016) Inter-romantic proto-triadicism and other-voicedness. M.I.T. Press

3. Katz, F. C. ed. (1999) Dialectic the Performance: Other-voicedness in the music of Saariaho. McGraw Hill

4. Mahler, Barbara (1980) Liberal/Conservative: Other-voicedness, Mahler, and rationalism. Cornell University Press

5. Rodin, U. V. S. (1976) Other-voicedness in the writings of Mann. Scarecrow Press

6. Fitzpatrick, Ludwig ed. (2009) Deconstructing Straus: Inter-romantic proto-triadicism in the works of Muhly. M.I.T. Press

7. Ingolfsson, O. ed./trans. (2011) Other-voicedness, rationalism, and the pre-textual concept of narrative. University of Illinois Press

8. Linklater, Rene (1991) Forbidden Seas: Other-voicedness and inter-romantic proto-triadicism. Edward Mellyn Press

Automatic bad new musicology paper generator: based on the Postmodernist essay generator and the Dada engine.


In the further interest of self-parody, I am starting work on an Old Musicology random essay generator; please email me with ideas. All I know is that every paper will begin "On f. 3v, a new watermark ..." etc.