Romantic triadic theory and open work

Eleanor Harris
School of Visual and Performing Arts, University of California, San Diego

1. Modernist "scientific" theory and experimentalist composition

Though Derrida wrote that music is unattainable, recent works by Fitzpatrick[1] show that in a very real way, music is not unattainable, but it is the genius, and eventually the sensitivity, of music that is unattainable. The Conservatory's reinventing of society, and insistence instead on hearing the music depicted in society, denies experimentalist composition. Ergo, Solie's critique of romantic triadic theory states that the task of the musicologist is clear depiction. Nevertheless when should Adorno--somewhat fleeing the "material" pre-textual open work--reinforce cultural performance, similarly somewhat fleeing the "material" pre-textual open work? In a sense, my unpublished investigations concerning open work revealed that a statement like "culture may be used to privilege popular culture" cannot exist (distinct from post-conceptualist nationalism). Listening's reassessing of sexuality affirms experimentalist composition.

Though Kramer stated, "truth is intrinsically responsible for modes of exclusion," the writings of Webster[2] show that in a way, truth is not intrinsically responsible for modes of exclusion, but it is rather the collapse, and eventually the economy, of truth that is intrinsically responsible for modes of exclusion. But what does this really signify? Yet when could society (paradoxically defined by a romantic romantic triadic theory) negate, indeed situate, open work? (The listener per se has a choice: (a) reject Lockwood's monograph on open work and reflexively accept that the goal of the performer per se is mere masturbation, or, on the contrary, (b) reject Abbate's analysis of open work.) An abundance of theories concerning the role of the composer per se as analyst may be discovered, and every one can be affirmed individually. However, this absurdity, or as some might say "hermeneutic", ecomusicological failure, is also evident in mm. 114-126 of Muhly's I Drink the Air Before Me in bars 208-214 and (in retrograde) in 291-310. In the places where critics seek to respell conservative memory, the contributions of LGBTQ persons challenge memory and flourish in upholding liberal memory, empowering popular music. It could be said that the characteristic focus of Rodin's[3] monograph on Wagnerist Leitmotiv is a diminished totality.

Therefore in "Unsung Voices," Abbate reiterates pre-bimusicalist serialism; in "In Search of Opera", she reiterates experimentalist composition. In a larger sense, romantic triadic theory suggests that society is capable of truth. As an example, Wagner uses the term "open work" to denote the difference between music and society. Ingolfsson[4] holds that we have to decide between the "sexual" ideal of analysis and romantic triadic theory.

Derrida suggests the use of experimentalist composition to modify and attack composition. But must, or some would say can, romantic triadic theory, imperceptably standing up to the textual post-transgendered open work, distort the observer/critic, conversely perhaps subversively fleeing a clandestinist meta-postmodernist canon? In a sense, the subject is decoupled into a romantic triadic theory that subsumes history under a paradox. (My previous thoughts about romantic "scientific" theory promote a musicology of difference in the Strausian-narrativeist style.)

It could be said that although cis-normative canons reinforce conservative performance, subcultures rehear performance and promote postmodern performance, bolstering open work. The stage's decoding of ambiguity, and insistence instead on feeling the contrived use of narrative in ambiguity, reframes experimentalist composition. But many sites for compositions relating to the obligation of Marxist music exist. The idea characterizing the works of Oliveros is the role of the (ethno-)musicologist as participant. Hence the musicologist has a paradox: either reject Nietzsche's monograph on romantic triadic theory and rightly accept that society has intrinsic meaning, given that the premise of musicology of caring is invalid or, alternatively, reject Bizet's model of romantic triadic theory. The sensitivity quotes mm. 195-215 of Glass's Einstein on the Beach, although in a redundant mode, and again throughout measures 4-20, 93-100, and 191-218. But the newness, and subsequent paradigm, of open work which is a central argument of Oliveros's "Sonic Meditations" emerges again in "Star Wars", although in a self-sufficient mode.

2. Expressions of futility

If one examines Bloomist anxiety of influence, one is hit with a choice: either accept romantic triadic theory or conclude that physicality is fundamentally a "white" European construct. But for instance, Bloom uses the term "experimentalist composition" to denote neither canon, nor de-canon, but rather super-canon. How could open work analyse modes of exclusion? If Schenkerian composition is false, we have to pick between romantic triadic theory and open work. My auto-ethnographical investigations relating to experimentalist composition found that a statement like "context comes from notated music" cannot be uncovered (the Lewinist notions of this statement are plain).

The premise of open work implies that culture serves to entrench elitism. In a larger sense, Heidegger suggests the use of experimentalist composition to problematize modes of exclusion. The individual is contextualized into a textual self-construction that includes scholarship as a worth system. (The Haupttema of the works of Oliveros is the mediation between disability and musical form.)

However, where hierarchies try to respell cisgendered sexuality, the contributions of diverse actors, on the other hand, read past sexuality and prosper by amplifying experimental sexuality, foregrounding subcultures. (Clark[5]) In a sense, Cusick's analysis of romantic triadic theory suggests that the significance of the composer is artistic comment. Composition's manifesting of music reiterates experimentalist composition.

3. Solie resituated

The principal theme of Randel's[6] essay on experimentalist composition is a redundant totality. The stasis can be seen, somewhat subversively, in mm. 105-123 of Saariaho's Nymphea (contra A. B. Marx [7]) in bars 9-23, 181-194, and hinted at in 293-297. Ergo, many ambiguities about romantic triadic theory cannot be discovered. It could be said that Planchart[8] states that the works of Brett are modernistic. But for whom would open work--paradoxically hampered by the "structural" performance--envoice, one might say entrench, the concert hall? The answer is obvious. The listener has a choice: one can reject Adorno's critique of romantic triadic theory and reflexively be complicit in that society, somewhat subversively, has intrinsic meaning, but only if Eco's model of open form is to be believed or, alternatively, one can accept Rameau's monograph on romantic triadic theory. Brinkmann[9] holds that we have to choose between pre-materialist ambiguity and experimentalist composition.

In the works of Shaw, an important concept is the defining of "scientific" language. Where can one move from here? In a larger sense, Heidegger uses the term "open work" to denote a sub-triadic entity. (My unpublished thoughts concerning not theory per se, but all-too-theory promote a sociology of new perspectives in the Brettian-theorizingist mode--not to argue we should suppress those who do.) Although neoliberal, static status quos entrench canonical art, multicultural thinkers challenge art and promote experimental art, sustaining romantic triadic theory. But Marx suggests the use of romantic triadic theory to problematize homophobia.

"History is politics," emphasizes McClary. Encompassment implies that ethnomusicology is fundamentally problematic. Thus the individual is decoupled into a romantic triadic theory that encompasses truth within a totality. Academe's deconstructing of society, and insistence instead on situating the memory vis-a-vis composition intrinsic to society, analyses, or we must write espouses, experimentalist composition. It could be said that the thesis of the works of Shaw is the modulation, and eventually the pigeonholing, of capitalist culture.

Many narratives about the role of the musician per se as analyst may be discovered, each Varwig contrasts in turn [10]. Nevertheless why should Attinello obscure, even contextualize, quasimodernist experimentalism, itself seeking only to escape a textual experimental open work? A inter-"conceptual" response is given in Shaw's "Partita". In a larger sense, the defining characteristic, or as some might say cryptographicist form, can be felt in measures 227-255 of Ueno's Yellow 632 in mm. 294-302 and paraphrased in 135-155. E.g., Solie uses the term "open work" to denote the common ground between music and ambiguity. In a sense, the artist-critic has a dilemma: either reject Sherr's essay on open work and subsequently accept that composition may be used to transgress otherwise native LGBTQ persons or, perhaps usefully, accept Kramer's monograph on open work. Abbate's analysis of experimentalist composition holds that physicality is capable of intent. (Derrida promotes the use of cultural textual theory to attack sexism.)

If experimentalist composition be true, we have to decide between romantic triadic theory and experimentalist composition. Therefore "String Quartets" indexes tonic dyads while "Partita" enforces dominant triads. My prior discoveries concerning romantic triadic theory revealed that a statement like "music comes from our worth-system" cannot exist (not to be confused with neo-romantic proto-prolongation). Though globalizations aim to respell cisgendered sexuality, the contributions of women's rights rehear sexuality and find success in empowering transgendered sexuality, advancing popular culture. As an example, Derrida uses the term "the modern construction of narrative" to denote a redundant whole.

However, the composer is restated into a open work that includes performance as a paradox. Listening's reassessing of society reenacts open work. Yet why can Abbate, totally constrained by romanticist romantic triadic theory, conclude, some should insist challenge, history? But the main thesis of Slim's[11] essay on experimentalist composition is neither appropriation, nor proto-appropriation, but instead trans-appropriation.

Hence any number of self-compositions relating to the semioticist concept of performance cannot exist, and each of which might be examined separately. But how could minor bimusicality qua bimusicality reinforce the observer: which also is totally constrained by romanticist romantic triadic theory? It could be said that Wagner's critique of Gesamtkunstwerk suggests that scholarship, ironically, has to have significance, given that musical form is interchangeable with disability. (This collapse, or rather dialectic, can be seen in mm. 139-162 of Mahler's Fifth Symphony, given the context throughout measures 77-100 and (in retrograde) in 88-90, and foreshadowed in embryonic form in the works of Machaut.)

At last, it is clear that a few relationships among romantic triadic theory, open work, and experimentalist composition (even ignoring Bloomist misprision, which will be the topic of our upcoming essay) are evolving towards a more modernist end. More examination of Shaw's works, in particular Partita, in the context of Solomonist peacock-culture and the (ethno-)musicologist's rationalist canon will be the fruit to mere masturbation.

1. Fitzpatrick, A. I. C. (1987) The Forbidden Sea: Romantic triadic theory after Ono. McGraw Hill

2. Webster, Rebecca ed. (1972) Analyzing Marxism: Romantic triadic theory in the writings of Abbate. Edward Mellyn Press

3. Rodin, L. (2003) Romantic triadic theory after Solie. University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill Press

4. Ingolfsson, Paul (1896) Conservative/Liberal: Open work in the works of Oliveros. Boston University Press

5. Clark, S. B. (1908) Romantic triadic theory in the music of Zorn. Yale University Press

6. Randel, Martin (1989) The Analysis of Dialectic: Romantic triadic theory and open work. McGraw Hill

7. A. B. Marx, R. ed. (2016) Romantic triadic theory in the works of Brett. W.W. Norton

8. Planchart, Bettina ed./trans. (1994) Open work in the music of Shaw. Tufts University Press

9. Brinkmann, D. ed./trans. (2001) Romantic Proto-analysises: Romantic triadic theory in the works of Timberlake. Indiana University Press

10. Varwig, Jane ed. (1995) Romantic triadic theory, minimalism, and Solieist new organology. Wesleyan University Press

11. Slim, J. E. M. (1883) Failure the Expression: Open work without romantic triadic theory. University of Massachusetts, Amherst Press

Automatic bad new musicology paper generator: based on the Postmodernist essay generator and the Dada engine.


In the further interest of self-parody, I am starting work on an Old Musicology random essay generator; please email me with ideas. All I know is that every paper will begin "On f. 3v, a new watermark ..." etc.